Posted by SFgenealogy on Sunday, October 31, 2010 at 14:19:36 :

MARRIED - In San Francisco, on the 1st inst., by Rev. Dr. Cox, at the residence of the bride's father; Hon. David GOODALE of San Pablo, and Ella E. BACHELDER of San Francisco.

Source: The Contra Costa Gazette (Pacheco, Contra Costa County, CA), 11 May 1872. Transcribed by Dee Sardoc.